Features of legal regulation of the activity of museums
https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-7306-2025-1-1-102-109
EDN: AVGHTW
Abstract
The purpose of the study is to identify the specifics of the legal regulation of museums, analyze the legal nature of "museum law", and determine the legal content of this right.
Theoretical foundations
In this paper, methods of analysis, comparison and generalization are used in the development of the research topic.
The legal uncertainty regarding the essential content of museum law generates many different approaches in theory. Such a disjointed understanding of the subject under study does not allow us to determine its legal nature and is a prerequisite for additional analysis.
The author notes that "museum law" belongs only to the museum, which is assigned the right of operational management of museum objects. Thus, there is a special legal entity, which is the museum itself, and which, by virtue of the law, has the corresponding right. This is the right to transfer the rights to use reproductions of museum objects and museum collections for commercial purposes, as well as a special right to publish fine, printed, printed and other replicated products and consumer goods using images of museum objects and museum collections. However, this right is not defined in the law. This right is similar in nature to the exclusive right to the result of intellectual activity, but does not coincide with it. If the term of the exclusive right is limited, it is alienable and the subject of this right is not strictly defined, then the "museum right" is indefinite and inalienable. However, in theory, there are different points regarding the duration of this right.
Results and conclusions
Currently, there is no unified approach to defining the legal nature of "museum law"; it is considered both a separate branch of law and a separate subjective private law. There is a need to continue scientific research in order to resolve the existing uncertainty regarding the legal nature of museum law.
The results of the study can be used to conduct further scientific research on this and related issues, including as a theoretical basis for studying the problems of reproduction of museum objects, and can also become a starting point for research into the legal aspects of museum legislation and legislation in the field of intellectual property.
About the Author
V. D. BurdovaRussian Federation
Veronika D. Burdova – PhD Candidate, practicing lawyer
Moscow
References
1. Burdova V. D. Dualism of the legal nature of museum rights. Works on Intellectual Property. 2022;41(2):54–59. (In Russ.)
2. Burdova V. D. The results of reproduction of museum objects and museum collections as quasi-objects of intellectual property in the digital age. In: Intellectual property rights in the digital age: selected aspects: a collective monograph. Issue 19 / hand. and scientific ed. by M. A. Rozhkov, Doctor of Law; introductory article: V. A. Korneev. Moscow: GAUGN Press; 2023. 438 p. –series "Analysis of Modern Law / IP & Digital Law"). Pp. 182–193. (In Russ.)
3. Burdova V. D. Museums as subjects of exclusive rights. Journal of the Intellectual Property Rights Court. September 2023;3(41):60–66. (In Russ.)
4. Burdova V. D., Egorova A. S. Features of the free use of works embodied in museum objects and collections for informational, scientific, educational or cultural purposes. Journal of the Court of Intellectual Rights. September 2023;3(41):112–119. (In Russ.)
5. Rybak K. E. Normative and legal regulation of the activities of museums. In: Law and culture: monograph. Under the general editorship of V. K. Egorov, O. N. Astafieva. Moscow; 2009. 464 p. (In Russ.)
6. Gavrilov E. O. On "museum law". Economy and law. 2015;3(458):71–81. (In Russ.)
7. Kozlova M. Yu., Kozhemyakin D. V., Sergacheva O. A. Quasi-exclusive rights to museum objects in the digital age. In: Law of the digital economy – 2022 (18): Yearbook-anthology / Hand. and scientific ed. by Doctor of Law M. A. Rozhkova. Moscow: Statute; 2022:129–153. (In Russ.)
8. Proceedings on intellectual property. Volume VI. Intellectual property law and information law: problems of law enforcement. Under the general editorship of Doctor of Law, Professor M. A. Fedotov. Moscow; 2003:6–24. (In Russ.)
Review
For citations:
Burdova V.D. Features of legal regulation of the activity of museums. North Caucasus Legal Vestnik. 2025;(1):102-109. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2074-7306-2025-1-1-102-109. EDN: AVGHTW